New Orleans in a Glass

We say yes.

Not only does the Sazerac cocktail sip like a dream but, with ingredients that include absinthe and Peychaud’s bitters, it also tastes like New Orleans in a glass.

The Sazerac really isn’t all that different from another classic cocktail, the Old Fashioned. Both Pre-Prohibition cocktails are boozy sippers made with a dark liquor, bitters and a sugar cube.

However, while a typical Old Fashioned is made with bourbon and Angostura bitters, the Sazerac replaces those ingredients with rye and Peychaud bitters and adds an absinthe (or pastis or Herbsaint) rinse for good measure.

But make no mistake. The Sazerac isn’t an Old Fashioned rip-off. How could it be? The Sazerac cocktail was invented in New Orleans decades before anybody ever sipped an Old Fashioned anywhere.

Discover more of our favorite Pre-Prohibition cocktails.

The Sazerac’s history dates back to the 19th century when the (now closed) Sazerac Coffee House first served the cocktail that Antoine Peychaud allegedly created at his French Quarter apothecary. His recipe included Sazerac-de-Forge et Fils cognac, absinthe and a secret blend of bitters. Almost a century later, Peychaud’s signature blend remains a key ingredient in any proper Sazerac. The other ingredients, not so much.

While we use absinthe in our Sazerac recipe, other recipes replace the potent anise-flavored spirit with France’s pastis or New Orleans’ Herbsaint. The reason for this recipe alteration goes back to 1912 when the US banned the sale of absinthe due to a concern that La Fee Verte (i.e. The Green Lady) caused hallucinations.

Although that hallucinogenic concern was disproved and absinthe eventually returned to the American marketplace with reduced thujone (found in wormwood) levels in 2007, not everybody in New Orleans got the memo. They continue to craft Sazeracs with Herbsaint, a local favorite, instead of absinthe.

Buy a copy of Tim McNally’s The Sazerac if you want to dig deeper into the classic cocktail’s past.

Perhaps the Sazerac would have achieved more widespread popularity had absinthe not been banned for almost a century. We’ll never know for sure. But we do know that the boozy beverage never lost its luster in its home city.

In 2008, the Louisiana’s senate made the Sazerac’s the state’s official cocktail. More recently, in 2019, the Sazerac House opened a multi-floor exhibition celebrating the cocktail’s history and offering Sazerac samples to all who take a free tour.

Make an appointment to tour the Sazerac House.

The Sazerac’s ingredient is relatively short considering the cocktail’s big flavor. Here’s everything you need to craft a classic Sazerac at home:

Ingredient quantities are detailed in the printable recipe card below.

Rye whiskey is the dominant ingredient in the Sazerac so you’ll want to use a good one. A solid choice would be to use Sazerac Rye produced by Buffalo Trace; however, we don’t have easy access to that particular American rye where we live.

We bought a bottle of Rittenhouse Rye with a 51% ABV for this and other recipes. Although it’s distilled in Kentucky, the liquor has a Philadelphia connection just like us. Its name was inspired by Rittenhouse Square located in the center of the city of brotherly love.

While you have flexibility in choosing the rye, this is not the case with the bitters. Peyhaud’s is the one and only bitters choice when crafting a proper Sazerac cocktail.

Not only was Peychaud’s bitters an original Sazerac ingredient all those years ago, but the ruby red bitters has a spicy blend that works well in this cocktail. Similar to Sazerac Rye, Peychaud’s is currently produced by Buffalo Trace in Kentucky. It has a 35% ABV.

Although absinthe plays a supporting role in the Sazerac recipe, it’s absolutely integral to the cocktail’s final flavor. Sure, you could use Herbsaint or pastis to get that hint of anise but we choose to use Absinthe as did Antoine Peychaud.

We purchased a bottle of Absente 55 Absinthe for this and other recipes. Produced in France and as its name suggests, the green liqueur has a relatively low ABV of 55%.

Before you start crafting a Sazerac, you’ll want to fill a lowball glass (also known as an old fashioned glass) with ice cubes and set it aside.

The first step is to drop a sugar cube into a second low ball glass and add four dashes of Peychaud’s bitters.

Measure the rye whiskey in a jigger. We use a Japanese jigger to ensure accurate measurement and avoid spillage.

Buy a Japanese jigger from Amazon if you need a jigger or want an inexpensive upgrade.

Empty the ice from the first lowball glass.

Measure and pour a half ounce of absinthe and pour it into the chilled glass. Swirl the glass so that the absinthe coats the glass’s interior.

The Sazerac cocktail is a beloved classic in New Orleans and beyond. However, we won’t judge you if you prefer crafting one of the following alternatives:

Discover 10 essential bar tools for the home mixologist.

Did you craft this cocktail? If so, please rate the recipe below.

Thirsty for More New Orleans Cocktails?