Amaretto Sour: Bourbon Makes It Better!

Reconnecting with the Amaretto Sour has been a sweet pleasure.

After drinking the sweet yet sour cocktail during our college years, the drink exited our cocktail loving minds over the past decades. We moved on. The version we had imbibed in our early 20s was concocted with store-bought sour mix and, to be honest, was more of a gateway drink than a crafted cocktail.

Times have changed and so has the idea of using cheap, subpar ingredients. Once we crafted Amaretto Sours at home with just a handful of wholesome ingredients, we had two questions…

First, we wondered why the Amaretto Sour isn’t as popular as other Italian cocktails like the Negroni and Aperol Spritz. And second, we questioned how soon we could drink Amaretto Sours again.

Discover more of our favorite Italian cocktails.

While our history with the Amoretto Sour dates back to the latter part of the 20th century, the drink’s history goes back to the 1970s. However, while cocktail historians suspect that the sweet cocktail was invented in the United States, nobody knows exactly who deserves credit for its creation.

Regardless of its creator, the sweet drink hit a nerve with the 70s disco generation before being relegated to fresh university students and octogenarian grannies. Most everybody between these two demographics eschewed the 70s era cocktail as ‘passé’ for decades.

Fast forward to the 21st century and bartenders like Jeffrey Morgenthaler have re-invented the Amaretto Sour by removing the sour mix and adding extra ingredients like bourbon and egg white. Some add maraschino liqueur to their Amaretto Sour recipes while others add a few dashes of Angostura bitters.

Since we use Disaronno Amaretto in our Amaretto Sour recipe, our cocktail is technically a Disaronno Sour. However, our recipe is different from the official Disaronno Sour recipe since we add bourbon and ‘dry shake’ the cocktail before adding ice. More about dry shaking later.

Based in Italy’s Lombardy region, Disarrono is the world’s most prolific amoretto producer. Its almond flavored liqueur has a 28% ABV but, ironically, doesn’t contain any almonds. Instead, Disarrono uses apricot kernels to achieve its sweet flavor.

Fun Fact
Amaretto is no unitasker. It’s also a key ingredient in amaretti cookies. Some bakers also add the liqueur to tiramisu, a popular Italian dessert.

Some cocktails have a specific recipe that rarely if ever changes. The Amaretto Sour is not one of these cocktails. In fact, it seems like every recipe is different beyond the drink’s two main ingredients – amaretto liqueur and fresh lemon juice. Even the garnishes are different, typically maraschino cherries, orange slices or both.

After taste testing a few variations, we settled on the following ingredients for our Amaretto Sour cocktail recipe:

Ingredient quantities are detailed in the printable recipe card below.

Our Amaretto Sour recipe includes two liquors – amaretto and bourbon. We’ve consciously chosen to use a higher ratio of amaretto compared to other recipes.

We also use less lemon juice than other recipes plus a relatively small amount of Four Roses bourbon. The result is a cocktail that retains its amaretto flavor and isn’t too tart.

Discover our favorite bourbon cocktails.

Adding an egg white results in a silky top layer that looks and tastes great. Feel free to omit the egg white if you don’t feel comfortable ingesting raw eggs or if you’re vegan. Another option is to replace the egg white with a tablespoon or two of aquafaba.

Discover more cocktails with egg white to craft at home.

The first step in this recipe is to measure the amaretto, bourbon and fresh lemon juice. We use a Japanese jigger to ensure clean and accurate measurements.

Buy a Japanese jigger from Amazon if you need a jigger or want an inexpensive upgrade.

The second step is to separate and measure the egg white. You can skip this step if you’re vegan or if you’re uncomfortable with drinking raw egg product.

Warning
Your cocktail won’t have a foamy top layer if you omit the egg white.

The third step is to measure a teaspoon of simple syrup. While you can buy simple syrup online, we prefer to make our simple syrup at home.

Pro Tip
Make simple syrup by mixing equal parts of water and sugar in a saucepan and just bringing the mixture to a boil until the sugar is dissolved. Remove from heat immediately and let cool.

The fourth step, shaking the cocktail, has two parts:

First, vigorously shake the ingredients without ice for about 10 seconds. This process is called a ‘dry shake’ and allows the egg white to emulsify.

Next, after adding ice, shake the cocktail for about 20 seconds until the ingredients are thoroughly mixed and chilled.

Pro Tip
There’s no need to ‘dry shake’ the cocktail if you omit egg white from the recipe.

The fifth step is to strain the cocktail into a coupe glass. You can use a lowball glass if you prefer.

Once you buy a bottle of Disarrono amaretto, you may wonder what else to do with the sweet Italian liqueur. Unless you want to stick with drinking Amaretto Sours, we suggest crafting one or more of the following cocktails:

Discover 10 essential bar tools for the home mixologist.

Did you craft this cocktail? If so, please rate the recipe below.

Thirsty for More Bourbon Cocktails?